Formed 2004 ... Herts 7s U14 Runners-up 2005 ... North Herts U14 team, Herts Youth Games 2005 runners-up (coached by Letchworth)... Herts Superteams U14 Runners-up 2005 ... Herts SuperTeams "Fairplay" winners 2006 ... Rochford 10s U17 Champions 2006 ... East Midlands 10s U17 Runners-up 2007 ... East Midlands 10s U17 "Fairplay" winners 2007 ... National 10s U17 5th place and "Fairplay" winners 2007 ... Herts 7s U17 Plate runners-up 2007 ... National 7s U17 Plate winners 2007 ... RFU "President's XV" Award winners 2007 ... Herts Superteams winners 2007 ... Midlands 10s U18 Runners-up 2008 ... National 10s U18 4th place 2008 ... North Herts U11 team, Herts Youth Games 2008 runners-up (coached by Letchworth girls) ... London and SE 7s U18 Plate runners-up 2008 ... Herts 7s U18s runners-up 2008 ... National 7s U18s quarter-finalists 2008 ... Gloucester City 10s U18 Bowl runner-up (6th) 2009 ... Worthing 10s U18 Plate runner-up 2009 ... National 7s U18 Plate winners 2009... Worthing 10s U15 Plate winners 2010... Worthing 10s U18 Shield winners 2010... Herts 7s U15 and U18 Bowl runners-up 2010... National 7s U18 Plate runners-up 2010...
Showing posts with label National Cup. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Cup. Show all posts

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Maybe it was the National Cup after all...

Whatever the press release may have called it, witnesses to the event who have (very speedily) contacted me confirm that the 2010 "National 10s" was definitely not the like the National 10s of old. To begin with - in a worrying example of administrative dyscalculia - it seems that teams in this version of the National 10s actually fielded 12 players. Go figure, as they say.

However, the biggest give away was in how the teams were made up. One of the great things about the real National 10s was that the teams were - for the most part - genuine club sides. In a couple of cases clubs may have clustered, but even then the players were always a genuine cross-section of the clubs concerned. It was a real club tournament for real club teams.

The National Cup has - for the rules reasons mentioned earlier - never been quite the same. In most seasons the number of real clubs capable of entering on their own could normally be counted on the fingers of one hand - if not the thumbs - so teams (though they might play under a club name) have invariably "borrowed" players from other clubs. However, these have rarely been ordinary players - when it comes to creating a team "clubs" concerned have traditionally entered into a kind of rugby arms race. Considering there are only about 30 TDG girls in each age group it is amazing how many can be found in the average National Cup "club" team!

And so, in the best traditions of the naked win-at-all-costs ambition that has been such a feature of the competition over the years, one "club" reportedly this year fielded at least seven - SEVEN - TDG girls (a new record?), three of whom were borrowed from another club to help them "make up numbers) (isn't amazing how the only girls available just happened to be TDGs?) while most of the others had (allegedly) only been registered by the club very recently - some correspondents say within the previous week! Another "club" was basically a regional team in club shirts, a third was mainly one of the leading county sides, and another featured three "ringers" from, well, Letchworth Saracens.

Its all a bit - well various words springs to mind - perhaps the kindest would be "pointless". I mean what the heck does it prove if a bunch of country's leading players are cherry picked, stuffed into a club shirt they have probably never worn before (and never will again), and sent out to "represent" a club. I'm sure the trophies and medals looks magnificent in the various clubs' cabinets, but they are hardly deserved. Winning a trophy with the help of a quarter of the country's TDG players (most of whom will have been introduced to the game by someone else) just shows which coach has the best connections (and phone book). It is certainly not any recognition of the recruitment and training abilities the club may have.

Of course this not really the concern of most real clubs - the National Cup is not and never has been a true club competition, and their best players are only borrowed for one weekend - and there won't be a National Cup next year anyway. However there will be the new National Leagues, which will (apparently) result in a national final. Given that these will be run by the same RFUW officials who administer the National Cup, and that the naked ambition behind many of the National Cup sides will still exist, what is to stop the leagues being just as dominated by the same sorts of artificial teams - a fact that would be rather more dangerous to the continued survival of real clubs?

  • A thought. If the aim of the National League is to extend and broaden the base of the game (and if it isn't it should be - the elite players already have Divisions and TDG and Player Pathways) then why not actually have a limit on the number of Divisional or TDG players a team could field? If a club happened to have too many then maybe it could lend players to weaker opposition, thus making more competitive matches and allowing more girls to learn from playing alongside talented team-mates. Doesn't that sound a more sensible idea than RFUW's suggestion that all the best players gravitate to a small number of elite clubs? Or have I missed something?

Friday, May 14, 2010

Rewriting history

There are times when you read an RFUW press release and think that you have fallen into some parallel universe. Take this one, issued last weekend. It includes such statements as...
On Saturday, in torrential rain, the National Under 15s 10s tournament took place. ...
On Sunday, Lichfield hosted the National 10s Under 18s... The final of the National U18s Cup saw last year’s winners Reading Baa Baas take on London Irish, with London Irish this time triumphing 20-10. The RFUW Fair Play award also went to North Dorset RFC.
Just a minute WHAT NATIONAL 10s???!!!!  Everyone will remember that last year - after two successful years - the National 10s was cancelled as there was (according to the RFUW) no demand for it. It is why the Gloucester 10s came into being - to fill the gap created by the cancellation. The decision to cancel the 10s was staggeringly unpopular but was not reversed for 2009/10 - there was nothing in the calendar and no general invitations were sent to all clubs - so where on earth did this tournament come from? And how did those clubs who took part get invited?

The answer - after a bit of digging and investigation (ie. working out what Reading did win last year) - this seems to be that a replacement for the National Cup, which was cancelled this year due to a lack of entries (the National Cup was completely different to the National 10s, being a tournament for 15-a-side teams - indeed, thanks to the rules, 15-a-side teams who could field squads of 22. It is small wonder that so few clubs entered!). At the last minute, without telling anyone, it seems to have been changed into a 10s tournament (a format that, according to RFUW only a year ago, no-one was interested in), and that only those teams that had entered the National Cup were invited to this competition instead.

It does not seem to have crossed the minds of anyone at Twickenham that a whole stack of clubs who were not interested in the National Cup would  have been interested in the National 10s, clubs that (going by my email box) are now ever so slightly upset about not being given a chance to play this year!

Even more remarkably this is not the only weird, strange and unexplained RFUW tournament advertised in press releases this week - there is also...

The Mysterious Case of the St George's Day Sevens.

This is a new, high profile, national sevens competition that will be played at Twickenham for the next three years as part of the "legacy" of the World Cup. Teams from "across the country" took part in the first edition apparently - 150 girls in all (hmmm... only about a quarter of the size of Herts Sevens then)?

At Letchworth we have always enjoyed Sevens, so why did we not take part? Very simple - because (as with the "National 10s") we were not invited. Nor were Saracens - or, so far as I can gather, about 99% of the nation's clubs. Quite how those teams who did take part got an invitation is difficult to work out - looking at the report it seems to be a curious mix of random school teams with (for some reason) the odd club like Liskeard thrown in. Still now we all know about it maybe clubs outside a select few will get a chance to play at Twickenham next year? Though, there again, maybe not as it doesn't appear in the "final" calendar for 2010/11...

Fact is that a new Sevens tournament would be an important development as most existing (and larger!) Sevens tournaments, including Herts 7s, are under threat next year. It is a strange sort of "legacy" that allows tournaments like Working, Dorking 7s and Herts 7s to disappear and be replaced by closed, select, invitation events.

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

National Cup correction

It seems that I have been misinformed about Thornbury's withdrawl at least. My apologies to all involved.

Even so the main points remain. It is difficult to understand why national resources are being directed in support of a competition that attracts a handful of entries (9 U18 teams and - I believe - 13 U15 teams?) while other, more popular, formats have been cancelled. Fifteen (or thirteen) a-side rugby may be important, but at this stage in development very few true club teams can come up with squads large enough to take part in this sort of event, especially with the rules as they are. As a result three days in a wildly overcrowded calendar set aside for the event also seems just a bit excessive - the knock-on effect of the tournament ultimately restricts as many playing opportunities as it creates.

But in addition - and the main thing that made all this worthy of mention - was that the format chosen in the south was extraordinary and worthy of comment. At least some of the clubs involved were far from happy - which is why information about it found its way to here. Good luck to those who do go to the second day, but really two days - and two long journeys - should not have been necessary for the task of reducing five teams to one.

Monday, April 06, 2009

Looking ahead to the Nationals

With two days to go before the official close of entries there are still a number of vacancies in the U18s National 7s entry. Last year there was actually a waiting list because around 20 teams tried to entry the competition but in truth that was quite unusual - most  years the entry date tends to to be extended and we normally get a full 16... unless someone withdraws on the day of the competition.

So far the website lists 10 entries, and most of the big names are there - Worcester, Tynedale, Reading, Paviors, Exeter. A few "new" names as well, but no Darlington, Wimborne or come to that Basford yet. However its not clear when the page was last updated, and its difficult to believe that these teams will be absent.

The U15 tournament is also filling nicely and should have a full complement - although we are not in it. Well, at the moment, though I guess if the girls continue to grow into the game as did on Sunday we may try to get them in yet! However, the adult 7s is in real trouble. The RFUW currently list only TWO entries out of a possible 32 - even with a late rush that does not sound promising. 

One reason for this is that the cost of entering the adult event this year is a remarkable £150 (more than twice the fee for the junior sevens) - which is a heck of a lot for a single day's competition. But more importantly the RFUW no longer has a monopoly when it comes to the provision of high profile women's rugby tournaments. The RFUW 7s is on the same weekend as the big, highly commercial, well organised, heavily promoted and cheaper Bournemouth 7s. Bournemouth also allows squads of 14 instead of 10 - and already has 28 entries for its two women's tournaments over the weekend.

The concern must be that, if the RFUW's adult 7s is cancelled, what will happen to the junior 7s - if not this year, then next? After all the loss of the junior 10s only makes sense if it resulted from the failure of the adult event. 

This means that the "safest" club junior tournament run by RFUW is also now comfortably the least popular one. With Oakmedians failing to show up for the first day of the southern qualifier the U18 National Cup is down to nine entries! One positive should have been that, with only five teams left, it would have been possible to complete the qualifier in a single day. At least three of the entrants wanted to do exactly that... but I understand that RFUW refused to allow them to do so! 

The tournament itself is only halfway through - but it already looks like Reading will win it after two comfortable wins over Welwyn and Exeter. Wimborne, Welwyn and Thornbury may have an interesting (but, in any practical sense, meaningless) battle for second place, with Welwyn just having the edge at the moment, but the most fascinating question about the qualifier now is not who will win but who will turn up for Day 2. Exeter are out of it after two defeats and are faced with a totally pointless 400 mile round trip in three week's time. Will they make the journey? Would you?

Friday, April 03, 2009

Defining "popular"

Further to yesterday evening's bit on the National Cup, feedback reveals that apparently only four teams have entered in the North/Midlands - so that is ten teams in total for the entire country at U18s. As a result of this the North/Midlands first round has been abandoned completely - and frankly the southern round could have been disposed of in a single weekend as well with a modicum of imagination (see below).

U15s may be doing slightly better - certainly the Worcester U15 blog reveals a full complement for the first round in that region at least - but really it does again raise the question of the frankly mysterious and inadequately explained cancellation of the 10s. Its interesting the note that the Gloucester 10s - despite the problems imposed from outside, and despite being (for inevitable geographic regions) a south/midlands event - also has 10 U18 entrants. And why - again - was the 10s cancelled for "unpopularity" despite having more entrants when last played?
 
You will note that the National Cup - despite being an irrelevence for over 90% of junior clubs - already has three dates in next year's calendar. Why not use one of those dates be used for a revived National 10s?

Thursday, April 02, 2009

This weekend: Aylesbury away, and the parallel universe of the National Cup

A reminder that on Sunday we are away to Aylesbury, both U18s and U15s. Meeting at the club at 11.00. This will actually be our first visit to Aylesbury - address: 

Aylesbury Rugby Football Club
Ostler's Field
Brook End
Weston Turville
Aylesbury
Bucks
HP22 5RN

Meanwhile in a parallel universe the National Knock-out kicks off. Despite over 100 clubs being eligible to enter, the competition has again failed to find 16 entrants this year - yet somehow this means it is still "more popular" than the National 10s as it retains its place in the calendar next year whereas the latter event was, as you will recall, dropped.

That aside we didn't enter again this year, partly due to concerns that our playing strength was not big enough on our own (were not part if a registered cluster "on registration" - ie. at the start of the season - so also could not combine with anyone else), and partly because in previous years the tournament has often included teams of - how can I put it? - an "unusual strength" for an allegedly club rugby event. Obviously there is no evidence that this will be happening this year...

Indeed this year's Cup hides evidence of some good news of massively successful (but unreported) recruitment drives. Several of the clubs who have entered this season are only Category B members of RFUW, which means that at the start of the season they had fewer than 15 playing members. Yet now, without combining with any other clubs (or, presumably, poaching their players), they are able to enter a competition that - in effect- requires squads of experienced players numbering in the twenties. Well done to them!

Meanwhile, partly as a result of the failure to fill all the places on offer, the format of this year's event is, well, "original" might be a good word. Details from the north are, as usual, a shade sketchy but I hear that in the south the South East and South West qualification rounds have been combined.

Six teams (Reading, Thornbury, Exeter Sarries, Oakmedians, Welwyn and Wimborne) have all been placed in a single group, and each team will play all of the others over two weekends in Reading (5th and 26th April) with the winner goes to the final.  The games are 15 mins each way, with two games on one day and three games on the next. Which I guess sounds great on paper - except for the fact that it breaks rather spectacularly a basic guideline for any sporting competition - the one that says "Avoid Dead Rubbers".

A "Dead Rubber" is a match in a tournament where one, or both, teams taking part have already been knocked out. Its a safe bet that, as a result, the teams concerned will rarely play at their full abilities - indeed it is not unusual for teams drawn to play in "Dead Rubbers" to withdraw from such matches altogether, going home rather than "risk players in games that don't matter".

The above format does not so much break that rule as batter it to death with a sledgehammer before jumping up and down on the pieces. Consider... to win the group you really cannot afford to lose more than one game - at most. It is not impossible, but it is statistically very unlikely that a team with two defeats will stand any chance of going through.

But it is inevitable - assuming there are no tied games - that at least one team (and probably two) will lose both of the opening two games. Given that... why the heck would they bother returning for next round of games three weeks later? Why trek from, say, Exeter to Reading (and good 300-400 miles round trip) to play a series of (for you) meaningless fixtures? In fact, by the time you complete the third round of games at least half of the teams in the group will inevitably be "knocked out". When you work it out, at least a third of all the games will be "dead rubbers".

Why should this matter? Well, even if the teams do show up, if you are playing a crucial game against another team who are still "in" the competition, how fair do you think it will be if a rival on the next pitch is up against opponents who are, mentally at least, already on the bus home?

And why go to all this needless expense (ie. preparing and hiring grounds, and busing 100+ girls from across south of England twice) when the competition could be wrapped up with two pools of three and a final (plus classification games) on a single weekend? Madness. But fortunately madness we do not need to worry about!

Sunday, June 29, 2008

No National 10s in 2008/09!

Part of the pack given out at yesterday's conference included the latest draft of the "calendar" for 2008/9. Little has changed from earlier drafts - the indefensible block of regional dates after Christmas remains - but something I now realise that is not listed is the National 10s.

This seems - to put it mildly - extraordinary. Indeed words such as "ludicrous", "ridiculous", and "unbelievable" also apply... and others less printable. It also - if the information Worcester have been given is correct - seems to be true.

We all know that the National 10s was not a happy event for the RFUW, first having to rearrange the U18 event due to a small ground booking oversight, and then having to cancel the adult finals when several leading clubs decided they could not be bothered to attend. But that was no fault of the teams who DID turn up.

For U18 clubs - and smaller adult teams - the 10s has been a major event. More real U18 clubs enter the 10s than enter the National Cup (which you will note is still timetabled for 2008/9). This can be no surprise as (unless you have the resources of Worcester) the latter is only really accessible now to "clusters" (who, in the cup, increasingly seem to have a remarkably similar player make-up to regional teams), while for smaller adult teams it at least gives them a chance to play their "betters" on a numerical par. For RFUW to drop the tournaments because of last season's problems that were mainly of RFUW's own making (and certainly not the participants) is grossly unfair slight on these clubs who did nothing wrong.

One thing that was mentioned by several speakers yesterday was the fragility of the women's and girls' club game - the strong England team is in reality supported on a foundation of egg-shells. Dropping a tournament like this does nothing to improve matters. For most clubs the only chance to take part in an RFUW event is now the National 7s, and that one day in May 2009 is a long way off.

Its not too late for RFUW to change its mind - after all they managed to invent an entire U18 superleague for elite players two-thirds of the way through last season, so it cannot be impossible for them to do something similar for the grass roots. If you agree please drop a line to National HQ - Keeley Fathers (if you have her address) or just rfuw@therfu.com, or maybe your regional co-ordinator, or both.

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

The National Cup - what is it for, exactly?

[Dear Reader. It is possible that some people of a nervous disposition may become agitated by that which follows, or read into it all sorts of slights which are not there. If that is the case could I first please direct your attention to this note, and secondly suggest that you direct you wrath to a more constructive end by engaging in the discussion via the comments link at the end. Open debate is a wonderful concept - its how we improve things].

With the first ever RFUW Junior 10s this weekend, it was interesting that last weekend the “other” club competition was still an the object of discussion among several people I spoke to at Rugby. Apparently some even have heard that the National Cup is being reviewed – I do not know if that is so, but if it is it is so its not a moment too soon and is a debate that everyone who cares about the club game should be involved in.

After all, The National Cup is – or should be - the premier club rugby competition for girls teams. A competition that everyone aspires to, thinks about, dreams about even. But it isn’t.

In fact over large swathes of the game its an irrelevance, ignored by the vast majority of clubs. Out of the whole south-eastern quarter of England (containing half of the population of the country) only four teams took part this season. FOUR. And three of them were from Herts. Other areas barely did better than that - over the whole country the number of entrants just about staggered into double figures.

The reason for this indifference is simple. To be remotely competitive you not only need to be able to field a full XV (difficult enough for many clubs), but you also need a pretty full subs bench too as opposition player numbers are not reduced if you suffer injuries.

In the real world the number of clubs capable of pulling together the 20-25 girls needed directly from their own membership can be counted on the fingers of one hand. With fingers to spare. As a result sides combine forces - as we did this season (and would do next) – or otherwise field “guests” from other clubs.

This means that the vast majority of entrants end up being, in effect, artificial combinations created for the sole purpose of entering the cup. When even superpowers like Welwyn feel the need to reinforce their squad with a few "guests" alarm bells should start ringing, and when you hear that the winning team featured players from five different clubs, resulting in a team with a remarkable five TDGs in it (more than most regional sides can manage!), you do not need to be told that something isn’t quite right.

The trouble is that is anyone ever dares to question this or even mumble “erm… just a minute here” the world falls in. “None of these girls could have played otherwise because their own clubs are not big enough” you are told, and “how dare you suggest that anything underhand was going on – no-one is breaking any rules”. You even get threatened with being thrown out of the competition.

So please do not think that I am not remotely attempting to have a go or criticise anyone or any club for using the rules to their advantage. I am not – good luck to them. They are not at fault - its the rules.

Because fact is that it would be quite stratospherically difficult to break the rules on player selection as, to put it bluntly, there aren’t any. The players do not have to be members of, or registered with, or have previously played for, the club they turn out for.

Indeed you do not even have to go to the pretence of entering under the name of an affiliated club at all! There is absolutely nothing to stop Hertfordshire - or even East Region - entering the Cup next year AS Hertfordshire (or East)! Indeed there is nothing to stop someone signing up a complete squad of TDG girls from across the land if they wanted to.

So what is the point? What is the RFUW expending all this time, effort – and money – to achieve? Because it clearly isn’t a “club competition” – certainly not one for ordinary rugby clubs representing ordinary communities (unless you define your “community” as an area in excess of 1,000 square miles). It is, in effect, an event for invitational teams – with the winner being potentially less the “best club” as the club with the “best contacts" or the “biggest phone book” – and what does the game gain from that?

As a result it is small wonder that most clubs vote with their feet and that consequently winning it carries little glory. I know who won this year as someone told me, but I challenge anyone to tell me who won in 2005/6 as even the RFUW website seems silent on the issue!

So why is the RFUW persisting with a format that most clubs do not care about, that generates more ill-feeling than anything else, that forces clubs into something close to a player arms-race, and which has – moreover - been largely abandoned at senior level?After all, its not as if there aren’t alternatives.

One idea I have heard suggested is that - if a 15-a-side event is sacrosanct - then eliminate the temptation to cherry-pick superstars and make it an event for “ordinary” club players by simply running the tournament on TDG training weekends.

It’s a nice idea – after all the RFUW does damn all for the ordinary player most of the time, other than maybe killing off their season between Christmas and Easter by allowing the regional programme to wipe out every other weekend (or three weekends in four, if the latest draft for 2007/8 goes ahead). But in practice it would require even more combining to go on, and there are plenty of “well-known” girls on the fringe of the TDGs who would become the next targets.

So why not regularise the inter-club mixtures by making it a County Cup? After all the RFUW currently does nothing at all for the county game and at least a county-based competition would result in a proper definition of who could, and who could not, play for a given team. RFU have a tried and tested set of rules based on years of experience.

Trouble is that, in practice, neither of these solutions help clubs - real, local, individual clubs - the bedrock of the game. What is needed are competitions that even relatively small – but genuine - club sides can reasonably enter on their own.

Which brings us to this weekend, and Regional/National 10s. The entry for this wasn't great this season - but stuck at the fag end of the year on hard grounds and clashing with major exams it was hardly set up for success. However fact is that 10s tournaments in the main season work well - look at the Rochford 10s, or Worthing, or Exeter, or... well, many others.

Okay some clubs might still be tempted to get in a few, well, "ringers", and in the end that is difficult to legislate against (there is a bit of a contretemps going on in the US over a similar issue), but it would be far more blatant in a 10s so most clubs would not have the brass neck to do it. Well, one lives in hope.

Moving the 10s to the main season would also give more space to the evolving "7s circuit" (Dorking, Herts, Nationals) – another format that “real” clubs can enter. It may not be the "proper game", but at least it gets girls playing a form of rugby that is accessible to even the smallest team.

So what do you think? Do you agree? Am I barking up the wrong tree? Am I talking nonsense? Do you care?

If you do have a view, why not leave a few comments? And while you are about it, why not write to RFUW as well? Regardless of your views – whether you are in favour of the status quo or not – the centre needs to know. They do not have a monopoly on wisdom at Twickenham.

Its your game.

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Remember the National Cup?

The final was last weekend - you will recall that if we had beaten Wimborne by sufficient margin it would have potentially mucked last weekend up a bit?

Fortunately we didn't because a) we would have missed a great weekend, and b) we'd have been stuffed. Big time.

I say that with some authority because Peter, the Wimborne coach and reader of this blog, has emailed me the following details

"I thought I would update you on our National cup visit to Lichfield where we unfortunately lost to Leodonias 15-5. The game was as expected a tight game with Leos scoring in the first 5 mins before adding a second midway through the half. We then pegged them back with a score just before half time.

"The second half we were camped in their half for long periods of time but unable to break their lines of defence only for Leos to score a break away try to seal the game."

Leos a good side obviously - and congratulations to them on their win. Indeed they are quite outstandingly good - apparently they had five TDG girls on show, which is more than most regions can come up with (East, who I believe have more TDGs than anyone, have only six!).

Monday, March 26, 2007

National Cup: U17 photos now available.

Phil has done his stuff again for Sunday's National Cup - see here. Loads of really good ones, including....




Sunday, March 25, 2007

National Cup: a tale of two good days out

News from our U14s (playing with the "Hertfordshire Barbarians") is a bit thin at the moment, but after a win in their opening fixture they lost the next two, finishing third overall. In actual fact this was an impressive performance considering that in the end they only had twelve players, thanks to illness, injury (including our own "small" Hayley's broken elbow),and so on - so those girls had to play all three games without a break. Which I gather they did - against some pretty tough opposition too.

** Coach Simon Shutler has published a full report on the Herts website. **

Meanwhile "Letchbury" (or was it "Sudworth"? We really will have to agree out team names beforehand if we do this again!) U17s put in a truly "Legendary" performance at a pleasantly sunny Camberley.

Drawn first up against to play favourites Welwyn (who seemed to field a number of new faces, though Sasha said she knew a few from TDGs) our largely untried combination did extraordinarily well. Certainly it was impressive to see the first-half scrums where the Letchbury pack - many of whom do not even play county rugby - were more than match Welwyn's regional all-stars! Maybe if Joe hadn't switched the front rows at half time the result might have been narrower than the eventual 17-0 - Welwyn's second try certainly coming as a result of their pack capitalising on a now less powerful Sudworth front row. But the policy is always to play everyone fairly, and in the end even this pack was holding their multi-talented opposition - and by the players' reactions at the end of the game it was clear which team felt they had performed to their highest abilities.

Bouyed up by that - and now getting used to each other - Letchbury now took the other two-club combination "Ivelbridge" (Ivel Barbarians combined with Bridgewater), from Somerset. Very much your typical southern team with a fast back line but limited forward power, Ivelbridge had lost their opening game to Wimbourne 7-0 but came out of the blocks impressively. However the combination of Letchworth weight and Sudbury finesse really came into its own - the former stopping Ivels advance, and the latter shooting away to score. By half time Sudworth were 12-0 up, thanks to Sudbury's Jess using her "height" to sneak underneath the Ivelbridge defence and score under the posts. Well, it looked like that from the touchline because how she managed to get through other than by tunneling underneath is anyone's guess. Sasha added the extra two points, about which we will presumably hear for the next year or so.

Two more tries in the second half - including a Hayley special (scored despite her having been injured against Welwyn - thank you Iboprofen the wonder drug!) resulted in a famous 22-0 win over one of the best teams in the south-west.

News now filtered through that Welwyn had lost to Wimborne 7-5, which meant that a win over Dorset's finest would possibly see Letchbury into the final. In the end, though, Wimborne were staggeringly good and won comfortably 26-0. Sudworth could point to the smaller pitch, and could suggest that maybe if the game had come earlier and we'd been able to field a fit Hayley (who by now was asleep in the back of a car) and Stamerz it might have been different - like it might have only been about 20-0! Because Wimborne were just superb in all divisions of the game (even the forwards were pretty good, amazingly so for a southern side). Apparently many of the team are only 14 or 15, which is pretty scary!

And in the end it was also perhaps right to have a national club competition (all be it southern area final) won by the only team that seemed to come from just one club. Good luck to them in the final!

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

RFUW confirms details for Sunday

Both the U14 and U17 National Cup semi finals will start at 1.30, with dressing rooms etc. open from 12.30. All players should bring their own refreshments, though it may be possible to buy food and drink on the day.

RFUW are hoping to be able to send officials to each venue, but this may not happen to to illness and clashes with other events.

Both U14s and U17s will face a "round-robin" tournament involving four teams with matches 15 minutes each way. The draw for the order that the games will take place will be made at around 12.30.

In both cases two hours journey time should be allowed for - though if the roads are reasonably clear it could be much less - so (for those meeting at the club) the departure time will be 11.00.

Address and directions details can be found here:

Thursday, March 08, 2007

National Cup venues announced!

At last we know where we will be on 25th.

Those U14s who are in the Hertfordshire Barbarians team will be at Petersfield in Hampshire, and the U17s will be at Camberley in Surrey (home of "Cramberleigh"). In practice these aren't that far apart, and the girls clubs often play together as a single team.

The U14s will be up against Cranberleigh (from Surrey), Ellingham and Ringwood (Hampshire), and Thornbury (Gloucestershire), while the U17s will face Ivel Barbarians (Somerset), Wimbourne (Dorset) and Welwyn (name seems vaguely familiar...).

Both days will be a round-robin tournament with the winners qualifying for the final on 15th April. Yes, that is when we are on tour in Devon which might be seen as indication of a certain lack of confidence by your team management but... well, when the tour was organised we quite possibly, in all honesty, didn't expect to get this far (certainly based on last season's performances) and if you do get through then... it'll be an interesting problem. On the plus side the coach is booked - just might have a different destination on the front!

What can be said about our opponents? Welwyn and Cranberleigh need no intriduction as we've played them already. We also played Wimborne at the National Sevens last year - its the game featured on this month's page in the calendar. Yes - the one played in a monsoon! They are in the same league as Worthing and Havant, and their website has some interesting match reports.

When it comes to the "unknowns" I had a look round on the web to see what I could find. Answer... not a lot!

Ellingham & Ringwood are from the New Forest I think, have a U14 and a Womens team, a fixture list that is a year out of date, and a rather different taste in calendars...

Thornbury are from Gloucestershire and their U17s reach the National Cup Final last season (no idea if they won or not - not even the RFUW website provides that information). Beyond that ... who knows? as their various websites (and they have many) are almost devoid of any information about their girls' teams. Well, I couldn't find anything so if it is there its well hidden. Going by their fixture list the girls play no games at all...

Ivel Barbarians are the most informative, seem genuinely proud of their girls, and do actually have some information on their U17s... though its not been updated for a few months as Sasha's potential nemesis is still the main story.

So, for what its worth, I think we win on websites!

But a thought. Why do so many clubs - even (especially?) clubs like those above with damn good girls' teams - give them such poor coverage? Why do most girls club websites not even have up-to-date fixture lists (like not even this season's)?

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Leeds: An apology

My unreserved apology to the Leeds side about the comment made yesterday about the alleged make up of their team in the National Cup.

It would appear that I was misinformed.

I have now removed the comment you have complained about and wish you good fortune in the final against... whoever may emerge on the 25th.

Tuesday, January 16, 2007

RFUW aim stamp out National Cup "ringers"

Interesting email today from RFUW about the National Cup. Probably needs no comment from me...
Hi Guys

I am dropping you an email to clarify the use of players in the Cup Competition, as currently there are various rumours circulating about clubs hoping to recruit players from Regional Trials for their Cup Matches.

Firstly a player can only play for one club in any competition, so even if a player transfers to your club they are cup tied and cannot play.

At the start of the cup we did allow clubs to cluster and join forces so the girls got to play rugby, i have a full list of which clubs have joined forces to fulfil their fixtures.

I also have a list of players that have so far represented your club in this competition, you are allowed to bring in players that are registered to your individual club for the next round who did not play in the earlier fixture but if you
wish to bring in any player from outside your club then either myself or Kean need to be consulted on the reasons why and we will decide if that player can be added to your squad.

If you need any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Many Thanks

Keeley

National Cup semi-finals postponed!

Shock news!

The National Cup semi finals for both U14s and U17s have now been postponed until 25th March. Regretably (but maybe not surprisingly) the idea of dragging teams from Somerset all the way to Hertfordshire did not win much support!

This means that our little "festival" - at home to Saracens, Ampthill and Milton Keynes - will now not take place, at least not on that date. Instead we'll be off to... who knows where - but maybe not Dorset (or at least not Wimbourne) as RFUW are looking for a neutral venue.

It will also mean at least one change to Joe's squad as unfortunately Randy now will be unable to play.

It also means we probably revert to Plan A for 4th February - a visit to Sudbury!

Monday, January 15, 2007

U17: National Cup Sqaud

Below are the names of the 25 players we would like to take to the National Cup Semi Finals on the 4th Feb.

Forwards:
R Randall
L Watson
C Kelly
G Eagles
C Hughes


H Stammers
S Hargrave
N Birch
N Parnell
H Guilder

E Vivian
S Acheson


Backs:
K Alcock
S Bolland
N Alcock
M Mayers
L Dzobia


A Marshall
R Randfield
N Threlfall
J Robinson
J Maxwell-Tingey

G Alderton
H Watson
T Thompson

The following are asked to be on standby in case of injury.

J Ryan
J Rayner


If you are listed above and can't play on the 4th Feb or have any other problems please email me at daddyrandall@hotmail.co.uk.

Thankyou to all that played yesterday, it was a brilliant day of rugby.

U17: Cup squad

A big thankyou to all that participated yesterday from both clubs. It hand't dawned on me exactly how difficult selecting the squad was going to be.

My apologies for the delay in naming the squad but am waiting for confirmation on player names. As soon as I get this information the Squad will be named here.

Watch this space!!!!!!

Thursday, January 11, 2007

National Cup: U14 and U17 news

For the first time it has been confirmed that the following teams are in the "Southern Finals" in the two age groups:

U14s: "Herts Barbarians" (ie. us, Saracens and Eastern Cos) opponents will be Cranberleigh (Surrey/Hants), Ellingham and Ringwood (Hampshire), and Thornbury (Somerset).

Finding information about U14 teams is hard work but Cranberleigh we know about, Thornbury reached the National Cup final at U17 level last year, and Ellingham had a habit of winning lots of Plate competitions in 2005/6 but no-one has bothered to update their website for 2006/7.

U17s: Confirmed as Welwyn, Ivel Barbarians (aka "Ivy-bridge"), and Wimbourne

Venues: Now this is the interesting bit. No venues have been arranged yet as many of the likely grounds are still waterlogged. A note has been sent to RFUW saying that Letchworth is okay but we can't expect lightning to strike twice. Still, fingers crossed - maybe the more its rains the less likely we are to need to travel anywhere...

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

This Sunday @ Saracens

Or the "Bramley Lido" as it briefly became last time we tried to travel down there. And looking out of the window I'm getting a bit concerned again...

Assuming flippers and snorkels are not required this time the kick-off is due to be 1pm. So meet at 11.15 for a departure of 11.30, to arrive c12.15.

The fixture includes both Saracens and Sudbury and for both age groups this will - at least partially - be a trial day for the cup semi finals. So the U14s are guaranteed a fixture!!!!!

For the U17s it is Joe's intention is to select the cup squad after the games. Simon - the Saracens coach - is reponsible for the U14 squad.

Getting there: Bramley Sports Ground, Green Road, Southgate, London N14. M25 west to Junction 24, then A111 south for 2-3 miles. Just after the road crosses the A110, Saracens's ground will be found on the left. See map.

Total Pageviews (since June 2009)

 
Sport Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory