However, the biggest give away was in how the teams were made up. One of the great things about the real National 10s was that the teams were - for the most part - genuine club sides. In a couple of cases clubs may have clustered, but even then the players were always a genuine cross-section of the clubs concerned. It was a real club tournament for real club teams.
The National Cup has - for the rules reasons mentioned earlier - never been quite the same. In most seasons the number of real clubs capable of entering on their own could normally be counted on the fingers of one hand - if not the thumbs - so teams (though they might play under a club name) have invariably "borrowed" players from other clubs. However, these have rarely been ordinary players - when it comes to creating a team "clubs" concerned have traditionally entered into a kind of rugby arms race. Considering there are only about 30 TDG girls in each age group it is amazing how many can be found in the average National Cup "club" team!
And so, in the best traditions of the naked win-at-all-costs ambition that has been such a feature of the competition over the years, one "club" reportedly this year fielded at least seven - SEVEN - TDG girls (a new record?), three of whom were borrowed from another club to help them "make up numbers) (isn't amazing how the only girls available just happened to be TDGs?) while most of the others had (allegedly) only been registered by the club very recently - some correspondents say within the previous week! Another "club" was basically a regional team in club shirts, a third was mainly one of the leading county sides, and another featured three "ringers" from, well, Letchworth Saracens.
Its all a bit - well various words springs to mind - perhaps the kindest would be "pointless". I mean what the heck does it prove if a bunch of country's leading players are cherry picked, stuffed into a club shirt they have probably never worn before (and never will again), and sent out to "represent" a club. I'm sure the trophies and medals looks magnificent in the various clubs' cabinets, but they are hardly deserved. Winning a trophy with the help of a quarter of the country's TDG players (most of whom will have been introduced to the game by someone else) just shows which coach has the best connections (and phone book). It is certainly not any recognition of the recruitment and training abilities the club may have.
Of course this not really the concern of most real clubs - the National Cup is not and never has been a true club competition, and their best players are only borrowed for one weekend - and there won't be a National Cup next year anyway. However there will be the new National Leagues, which will (apparently) result in a national final. Given that these will be run by the same RFUW officials who administer the National Cup, and that the naked ambition behind many of the National Cup sides will still exist, what is to stop the leagues being just as dominated by the same sorts of artificial teams - a fact that would be rather more dangerous to the continued survival of real clubs?
- A thought. If the aim of the National League is to extend and broaden the base of the game (and if it isn't it should be - the elite players already have Divisions and TDG and Player Pathways) then why not actually have a limit on the number of Divisional or TDG players a team could field? If a club happened to have too many then maybe it could lend players to weaker opposition, thus making more competitive matches and allowing more girls to learn from playing alongside talented team-mates. Doesn't that sound a more sensible idea than RFUW's suggestion that all the best players gravitate to a small number of elite clubs? Or have I missed something?






